Why AI reputation is the next thing to audit

Try something this week. Open ChatGPT, Gemini or Google's AI Mode and ask the question your customers would ask. “Who are the best X brands in the UK?” Or simply, “What do you know about X brand?”

One of three things will happen. You'll be there, and described well. You'll be there, but described badly. Or you won't be there at all, and a competitor will be recommended in your place.

Welcome to AI reputation. It's how your brand appears when AI answers questions on its customers' behalf, and for a growing number of buying decisions, it's the first impression you never knew you were making.

What is AI reputation? 

AI reputation is the picture of your brand that AI tools build and repeat. Whether someone asks about your products, your prices, your service or how you compare to rivals, tools such as ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google's AI Overviews pull together an answer from what's been published about you across the internet.

That answer might be accurate, outdated, incomplete or wrong. And unlike a search results page, where people can scan ten links and make up their own mind, an AI answer often gives one short summary and a handful of names. If you aren't one of them, you may never get a look in.

Why it matters now 

People are already using AI to decide. AI is becoming part of the consideration stage, the moment when people narrow a market of dozens of options down to two or three. Being left off that list is expensive, and you won't see it in your analytics, because the visit never happens.

From a behavioural science point of view, it's a familiar story. People look for shortcuts, and AI is a very convenient one. Whatever it says first, and whoever it names, gets the benefit of attention, familiarity and trust.

Four ways brands go wrong in AI answers 

  • You're invisible. AI doesn't mention you at all, even when someone asks about your exact category or location.

  • You're inaccurate. AI repeats old information: a product you no longer sell, a price that has changed, an opening time that's out of date.

  • You're overshadowed. A competitor with more coverage, more reviews or clearer information is recommended ahead of you.

  • You're misunderstood. AI gets the nuance wrong, and describes a premium brand as budget, or a specialist as a generalist.

Each of these has a different cause, and so a different fix. Which is why the first job is to find out where you stand.

Where does AI get its picture of your brand? 

AI tools don't have opinions of their own. They draw on what's out there, and the more consistent, credible and clear it is, the more confidently they use it. That includes:

  • Your own website. How clearly it says who you are, what you do and who for.

  • Press and online coverage. What trusted publications have said about you, and how often.

  • Reviews and ratings. What customers say, in their own words.

  • Directories and profiles. Business listings, social profiles and industry bodies, and whether they all agree.

  • Conversations. Forums, social media and anywhere else people talk about brands like yours.

This is why AI reputation isn't just an SEO job, or just a PR job. It's both, plus content, plus customer experience. It's the sum of your brand's footprint, and AI is reading all of it. 

How can you shift it? 

The good news is that AI reputation can be influenced. It takes work, and it's not instant, but the levers are ones marketers already understand:

  • Fix the foundations. Make sure your website, listings and profiles are accurate, consistent and clear, and that your site is built so machines can read it properly.

  • Answer the questions people ask. Create content that gives clear, useful, quotable answers to the questions your customers are putting to AI.

  • Earn credible mentions. Digital PR and media relations build the authority that AI draws on. Coverage in respected places carries weight.

  • Build proof. Reviews, case studies and customer stories give AI evidence to work with, and give humans a reason to choose you.

  • Correct what's wrong. Where AI is repeating something inaccurate, trace it back to its source and fix it there.

None of it works in isolation. That's why we plan it the way we plan everything at Leopard Co: starting with the behaviour we want to influence, researching what's driving it and choosing the levers most likely to shift it.

Step one: the AI Reputation Audit 

You can't fix what you can't see. So the first step is an AI Reputation (AIR) Audit, where we examine how AI tools represent your business when they answer consumer questions.

We look at:

  • Whether you show up. Across the main AI platforms, for the questions your customers are actually asking.

  • How you're described. Is it accurate, current and on-brand?

  • Who's appearing instead. Which competitors AI recommends, and why.

  • Where the information comes from. The sources shaping the answers, so we know where to act. 

From there, we can show you where the gaps and opportunities are, and what to do about them, in priority order. Because we're a full-service agency, we can also deliver the fixes, across SEO, digital PR, content and social, rather than handing you a report and wishing you luck.

Authentic intelligence, in practice 

Auditing AI is a good example of what we mean by AI²: using AI-powered tools to move faster, with authentic human intelligence to interpret what we find. Tools can show us what AI says about a brand. It takes experience to understand why, and to decide what to do about it.

AI will keep changing, and so will the way people use it. But the principle won't: the brands that are clear, credible and consistent will be the ones that get recommended. The sooner you know where you stand, the sooner you can start to shift it.

Need more information? 

Want to find out how AI describes your brand today? Get in touch with our talented team to book your AI Reputation Audit.